I definitely prefer the Venetia! I have both, but I definitely wear my Venetia more. It is more sophisticated and elegant looking, IMO. It does fit on my shoulder, but not if I'm wearing a coat. The middle strap does not bother me - though I thought it would before I bought one. I just leave it undone, or I just tuck the strap in the little leather loop without doing the buckle. Also, the 3 separate sections of the Blake drive me crazy! I prefer to just put everything in one main comparment. The Venetia holds more than the Blake, and I think it's a little lighter (though both are heavy). Good luck on your decision!