I had to call my insurance company (USAA) today about a claim for a lost piece of jewelry, and I once again asked the question about the two handbags that are quite valuable (my Kelly and a vintage Nantucket basket handbag). This time, I got someone who actually knew something.
I was told that both items are fully covered under my homeowners policy less the deductible (I have $500 deductible). They are covered for REPLACEMENT value, ie cost of a new Kelly and either a new Nantucket basket bag or a vintage one by the same artisan if it can be found). There is no depreciation as I carry replacement-value insurance. I would, however, need to be able to provide them with photos of the bags and sales slips or appraisals (the Nantucket bag). She said I should keep those in my safe deposit box in case of fire.
I feel MUCH better about this! What is important is to call YOUR insurance company and ask them!!! All insurance companies have their own individual policies on coverage and it's important to know what YOUR insurance company's policies are.