I like having thicker soles on the winter boots so these are my favorites (Ultras and Sundance):
Yeah I have to try on the sundance. I've loved them since they came out (for 2 or 3 years now) but never tried them on, I always thought they were "too much" - but the bottoms look like they have such good grip! I'm in between those and a pair of ultra's because their bottoms also look like they'd grip the ground - I'm in upstate NY and it FLURRIED earlier today which has me petrified, knowing the bad weather is coming so soon!
Can you wear them year to year? Would I end up trashing a pair this winter? I'm thinking about picking up a pair of Sunset Uggs, I'm tired of cold feet!
It depends on the bottoms. I bought a pair of classic shorts in sand and chestnut in November about 2 years back and by summer they were unrecognizable, dirty, had lost their shape, and stretched out from getting wet so many times in the snow and drying while on me. When uggs get wet you need to shape them, stuff em' with paper towels until they dry to shape. 2 summers ago I bought a new pair of chestnut classic shorts and last november I bought a new pair of sand classic shorts - and they're doing just fine, but I don't take them out in bad weather. So if you live somewhere where you'll want to wear them in snow/ice etc then I suggest you steer clear from the classic line and go towards the ultra's or something with a thicker, grippier (is that a word?) bottom. The classic's are SO hard to walk in on ice - though they are boots technically, they're really not made for snow or ice IMO because they have like zero traction.