I returned my walnut maggie because it arrived with two deep scratches on it and I came home with a medium size black leather brooke. I'm not sure I made the right decision. I kind of wished that I would've tried another maggie. I do like the brooke though. the large brooke was too large and sagged when I but my stuff in it at the coach store. I tried the zipper on every kristin that they had in the store and they were all sticking. I asked the sa about that and she said she knew about the zipper problem, so a kristin is out. I would really appreciate anyones opinion please. I know that the walnut maggie will scratch and if I scratch it then I'll deal with it but I don't want one coming to me already scratched especially one that was scratched as badly as the one I received from jax.