I had a similar experience with a grail CSGM supposed to be new. It had lots of pulls. I called them and returned it but they made me pay the return fee… I didn’t buy from them after.
Disappointing experience purchasing online from TheRealReal.com It's the first time I've purchased from them: a "grail" (for me) CSGM that was listed as in "excellent" condition and priced accordingly. "Excellent" according to the RealReal's website means no signs of wear at all, just doesn't come with a box or the inventory tag. The shawl's actual condition, on arrival, was really disappointing. It has at least 8 thread pulls in it, the care tag is coming off, and it smells to high heaven like someone stored it in incense (yuck--why do people do that?). It's frustrating and irritating--the shawl is the "grail" for me and I'd only once before seen it up for resale, years earlier on e-bay for an over-the-top price, but the condition is less than desirable and I'm really annoyed with TheRealReal for listing this as "excellent" when at best it was/is in "good" condition (as in, mostly intact, not discolored). It seems I can return it, so I might do that. But I'm also concerned they'll accuse me of somehow ruining the shawl in the two days since it was delivered to me, rather than accepting that they misrepresented its condition on the website. And I've noticed their photos are not sharp enough to see the detail of thread pulls (and even the care tag partly coming off) and of course the photos aren't going to tell you that the scarf gives off a strong incense smell. I guess I'm just venting, but also sharing my experience of purchasing a shawl from TheRealReal.com in "excellent" condition that is actually far from that.