A girl is offering her Marc Jacobs Carmen bag to trade on Craigslist and she likes my distressed Winter White Dior Gaucho. Should I trade? I'll be honest. I like my Dior, but don't know what to do? Mine is 100% authentic and she is claiming that hers is as well. Would you pick the MJ Carmen over the Dior Gaucho...I guess this is a biased forum, but I never purchased a MJ bag. The color is red. Let me know what you guys think.