Is this your "go to" color family? If so, I would keep them . I have many grey and black bracelets and to me they are all different and work better with different outfits, stacks and sleeve types. If you love this color family, you will use both, one is pink and one is purple. But....If you are just starting your collection and want to keep it small and versatile, then return. BTW, we are twins on the tosca, I think it's gorgeous and one of the only color CDCs in my collection. I love it more than the shiny crocs in this color family. Is it back or did you buy it from a reseller?