Tiffany Victoria cluster earrings or the classic Victoria earrings in medium? Please help...

[Sethe]

Hi everyone. I am desperate for your help. Recently bought a Victoria cluster earrings. I like it as it sparkles like crazy. However, it seems most of the ladies here prefer the classic style. Should I return it and save up to get the medium size Victoria classic? Or keep it and get the classic Victoria pendant on my next purchase? Or...get the matching pendant if I have to keep it? Please help me ladies as I have 10 days to return/exchange the item. TIA.

1st photo- my cluster earrings

2nd photo- which pendant to buy if I am keeping my cluster earrings. Classic Victoria pendant in medium size or cluster pendant?

3rd photo- Classic Victoria earrings in medium.

Pendant pictures @Catata and @Bunny_in_Love

 

[Julezah]

Hi! I vote to keep the cluster earrings.

I’ve read a few of your posts about these beautiful earrings. It seems like you love them! I’d keep them, and worry about which necklace to buy when you’re ready to make that purchase. I think both the classic and the cluster pendant would look beautiful with your earrings. (And I don’t think the cluster pendant would be too matchy.....it’s a gorgeous design. I’ve seen many people with matching earrings and pendants and it’s lovely.) I think after wearing the earrings for a period of time you’ll have a clearer idea of which pendant you prefer. Good luck deciding!

 

[Bag*Snob]

Keep the cluster earrings and get the cluster pendant.

 

[Sethe]

Hi! I vote to keep the cluster earrings.

I’ve read a few of your posts about these beautiful earrings. It seems like you love them! I’d keep them, and worry about which necklace to buy when you’re ready to make that purchase. I think both the classic and the cluster pendant would look beautiful with your earrings. (And I don’t think the cluster pendant would be too matchy.....it’s a gorgeous design. I’ve seen many people with matching earrings and pendants and it’s lovely.) I think after wearing the earrings for a period of time you’ll have a clearer idea of which pendant you prefer. Good luck deciding!

Yes, I posted this earrings on other thread hoping to get more opinions. What you said really matters.. Thank you very much.

 

[Sethe]

Keep the cluster earrings and get the cluster pendant.

Thank you for your time voting. It means a lot.

 

[Aporchuk]

The cluster earrings look beautiful on you! I would keep them and get a classic pendant. Good like with your choice.

 

[Sethe]

The cluster earrings look beautiful on you! I would keep them and get a classic pendant. Good like with your choice.

Thank you very much! So kind of you to share your opinion and your time.

 

[Nikki_]

I'd keep the cluster earrings. They look lovely on you.

 

[jssl1688]

I’m in the minority here. I prefer the classic Victoria with 4 marquise. The cluster, is as the name implies, a cluster of stones and I’m not a fan. I like when the design is sharp, fluid and distinct, the cluster just seems like a messy sunflower so it doesn’t sing to me. Buy what you love and not what’s popular on the forum. Good luck with your decision

 

[Sethe]

I’m in the minority here. I prefer the classic Victoria with 4 marquise. The cluster, is as the name implies, a cluster of stones and I’m not a fan. I like when the design is sharp, fluid and distinct, the cluster just seems like a messy sunflower so it doesn’t sing to me. Buy what you love and not what’s popular on the forum. Good luck with your decision

Thank you very much! Will definitely consider your opinion.

 

[Sethe]

I'd keep the cluster earrings. They look lovely on you.

Thank you Nikki

 

[filigreeheart]

Everything in the Victoria line is classic and stunning. Can't go wrong with any piece. That being said, I prefer the cluster design in the pendant over the earrings. I prefer the classic Victoria earrings, they are so understated and elegant, the cluster earrings are a bit more 'blingy' but some might prefer that style.

 

[Sethe]

Thank you

Everything in the Victoria line is classic and stunning. Can't go wrong with any piece. That being said, I prefer the cluster design in the pendant over the earrings. I prefer the classic Victoria earrings, they are so understated and elegant, the cluster earrings are a bit more 'blingy' but some might prefer that style.

Thank you so much. Your opinion really counts.

 

[MatAllston]

Both are stunning but I prefer the classic over the cluster. Go back to the boutique and try the classic on and then decide. I now have the classic pendant and I would like to get both the classic and cluster earrings down the road.

 

[razl62]

Hi! I vote to keep the cluster earrings.

I’ve read a few of your posts about these beautiful earrings. It seems like you love them! I’d keep them, and worry about which necklace to buy when you’re ready to make that purchase. I think both the classic and the cluster pendant would look beautiful with your earrings. (And I don’t think the cluster pendant would be too matchy.....it’s a gorgeous design. I’ve seen many people with matching earrings and pendants and it’s lovely.) I think after wearing the earrings for a period of time you’ll have a clearer idea of which pendant you prefer. Good luck deciding!

Well said @Julezah , Agree with you 100%. And @Sethe the earrings look perfect on you!