This or that flap ?

[stardust12]

Hello ladies! I need some help deciding which bag to go with.

So long story short I used to an own a black med caviar classic flap from the boutique with ghw that tarnished in less than 6 months of purchase, it was very disappointing especially for the price I paid for. Almost heartbreaking if I say do. I ended up selling it instead of fixing it and am currently thinking of purchasing one from consignment store despite all the risks I heard off. I preferably want an older model (not necessarily vintage but say 2015-2016 series).

I saw 2 bags at the RealReal in perfect condition from 2015-2016 series. When I looked at the bags one looked bit darker than the other (right bag on the first pic). They are both in great condition but I am not able to decide which of the two bags to go for especially because there’s 2z From first glance which bag would you think I should go for ? I do appreciate how the hardware is still intact and didn’t tarnish unlike my bag from last year.
Between the two at first glance which one should I consider?

Thank you in advance ♥️

 

[forgetmenot301]

The darker one on the right imo. The lighter one on the left looks like it has some wrinkling from not being stored properly at the base of the bag as well as some deflated quilts. The GHW also looks brighter to me.

 

[A bottle of Red]

The darker one on the right looks nicer to me as well

 

[lovejoysunshine]

Prefer the darker one on the right too, looks to be in overall better condition, with better flap alignment.

 

[yuzulife]

Yes, darker one!

 

[ItsPurseonal]

+1 right hand side

 

[SpicyTuna13]

Another vote for the right

 

[papertiger]

Right +1

 

[lvchanellvr]

Definitely the darker one.

 

[tlilrascal]

I also agree with everyone else. Right side. Caviar seems shiner.

 

[Cali2HI]

The one on the right looks better in my opinion.