I carried all the carryalls today (pun intended).
The Monogram version
The shape: The lady took it out of a giant dust bag. The bag was not flat packed (or could not be). It actually held its shape very well. When she took out the paper inside, it became more slouchy, but that also gave it a lot more character. Its also not as blocky as expected, quite curvy when you looked from the side.
Volume: Looks like it can hold 3 small pillows. Its between the size of the keepall 45 and the speedy 40. Talk about micro-niche. But the size makes it more unisex.
Price: Around US 950.
Feels like: It kinda felt like a speedy 40 or a mini-keepall with a stronger skeleton / structure. But its not as minimalistic as the speedy (which is the epitome of the "less is more"). It also lacks the old world charm of the keepall. My friends thought the bag had an instant classic-feel (ie euphemism for very "auntie").
Best suited for: A stoic older woman. Or a man who really wants a speedy.
Reviewer's tilt: Value-for-money (volume divided by price), new design that looks old, not destined for greatness. I think I'll pass