I think it is more of a design preference as far as which is preferred.
What is this about the handles peeling? This has popped up in a few threads and I don't know specifically what it means.
my speedy damier handles peeled and then when i got the speedy back from repair, there were stains there i know where not mine and it looked like it had been heaviely used while it was away from me. sadly i didnt take enough pictures before sending it in to prove my case, but i would in future take TONS AND TONS of pics of my item before sending it in for repair.
Personally the mono is the classic LV. I love the mono speedy. The handles can get dirty but I have had mine for 3 years and they still look lovely.
The damier speedy is one of my favorite bags, it is worry free! I love the damier print. It is LV without the more obvious logos. I love the red interior. I don't think you can choose one is better than the other.....simply decide which one to buy FIRST!!!! Then buy the other!!!!!
the serial number matches though...WOW... maybe they sent you the wrong bag back?