My husband hasn't picked out and bought me jewelry since our first (we're been married almost 16 years) wedding anniversary. What he picked out though, I didn't like so he's like "why bother" when you know what you want and what I pick out, you don't like. Thus, I usually pick out my own birthday presents, etc. from him. It takes the surprise and romance out of it but at least I'm getting something that I want and like. Let us know how this shakes out but you're not alone in that my husband says the same thing - that I have enough (when I don't think I do) jewelry.