Tan color bag. Mulberry medium lily or PS1?

[crazybagfan]

I was hoping to get a tan color bag since long time ago. But always change my decision to get safer color at the end. However the color is still always in my mind. I used to own a mulberry small Bayswater satchel at oak color but sold it without using because I scared of water stain mark.

Now I’ve found two tan color bag at very good price. One is mulberry medium lily in oak color and another is PS1 in saddle color. I love both style and own a PS1 in red color. I don’t own any mulberry bag now but I have a YSL niki bag in similar style.

I heard mulberry quality is going down recently and also always heard of quality issue of PS1. Anyway I’m happy with my red PS1 so far.

I can’t decide and need opinion. To me both also casual bag that suite my lifestyle. PS1 probably can hold my stuff but lily is simpler and elegant. I will spray them with colonial before using this time. I want to add tan color bag into my bag collection [emoji16]

Need you gals advice!

 

[serenityneow]

I like both bags but think the PS1 is much better than the Mulberry in tan. To me, tan is casual and the Mulberry is a dressier bag that might look great in black but falls flat for me in this color. I hate to complicate your decision, but Ralph Lauren also makes some beautiful tan-colored bags with a great casual/equestrian vibe. Good luck!

 

[crazybagfan]

I do love the PS1 too but already have a red one. I scared i won’t keep 2 same bags at different color. Unless I sell the red [emoji28] I agreed lily is more dressier and nicer in black. But my objective now is get a tan color bag [emoji16]