...They're completely different, yet maybe not so different to justify keeping both. I've talked too long. One more question to all of you who have been so kind and wonderful to share your opinions (and I value each and every one of you): is this "it" bag past its prime? I love love love both and that's reason enough for me to cherish one or both, but how do you think this bag will be style-wise in five years? Is it trendy or classic? I'm thinking both, but then again I'm still all googly-eyed and butterflies. Thank you all for your input!
I would also keep both. In my opinion this is a very classic bag shape, which will not get out of style. If you love this kind of shape and it suits your needs, keep them.
I think it is not about an „It-Bag“ Status anyway. It always comes down to what you like and whether you can use it well.
I still have bags, I love which people consider dated, e.g. the Marc Jacobs Stam or other consider childish, e.g. Cherry Blossom or Cerises bags from LV. Important is that I like them and love to use them.