wow, the vote is pretty unanimous on the peony. i'm going to play devil's advocate: i vote carly! reason being is that i see the carly as a more classic piece. the peony is more of a seasonal or trend piece. i'm sure there are ladies who will say that the peony is not a trend piece and is the type of bag that you can wear every spring/summer! but to me, it's more of a trend.
I'm with you!!
But for me, not only does it look like a "trend" bag to me, I just don't like the peonies!! I'm probably the only one who doesn't think it's pretty/nice. *lol*