Quick take: Beautiful, smooth colors but don't last and are in bad packaging.
Full review: These are soft eyeliners in beautiful colors that go on opaque in one swipe. That's where the good points end. I don't know what I expected since it's called a "smudge stick," but it is definitely not waterproof. It goes all over the place! After I wore the color Peacock on my upper lash line for about an hour to two hours, there was a hard line of color that transferred to my lid, blue all over my waterline and lower lashline, and even on my cheeks!
The click mechanisms are also highly unreliable. The first one I got didn't click up at all. I exchanged it, clicked it up to look at the color, and it wouldn't click back down! I was prepared to take it back for the second time, until some searching on the internet proved that they weren't even supposed to click back down! Every time I close it, the cap mutilates the piece that's sticking up. I will definitely stick to my oldies but goodies Urban Decay 24/7 liner and Chanel Stylo Yeux.
Full review: These are soft eyeliners in beautiful colors that go on opaque in one swipe. That's where the good points end. I don't know what I expected since it's called a "smudge stick," but it is definitely not waterproof. It goes all over the place! After I wore the color Peacock on my upper lash line for about an hour to two hours, there was a hard line of color that transferred to my lid, blue all over my waterline and lower lashline, and even on my cheeks!
The click mechanisms are also highly unreliable. The first one I got didn't click up at all. I exchanged it, clicked it up to look at the color, and it wouldn't click back down! I was prepared to take it back for the second time, until some searching on the internet proved that they weren't even supposed to click back down! Every time I close it, the cap mutilates the piece that's sticking up. I will definitely stick to my oldies but goodies Urban Decay 24/7 liner and Chanel Stylo Yeux.