Hello, I am the seller on the auction. I am long time lurker and, of course, avid Coach fan. So often we have people posting their Ebay problems that I thought you might find it interesting to hear from the other party.
Yes, the bag was new. It had been sitting in my closet, unused, in its original dust bag until I had to clear some room for new purchases. The bag had polished brass hardware so even though I carefully inspected the bag before sending it I guess I didn't look carefully enough to see the scratches that she described. I think that any bag with polished brass hardware that has been opened and closed, even once, will have small scratches on the closure. I offered her the option of a partial refund but she refused.
The bottom line is that she was not happy with her purchase and I certainly do not wish to stick anyone with something that they don't want, so she will return the bag and I will pay the shipping charges. I would hope to be treated the same way. I would prefer that she did not immediately accuse me of being a fraud and a liar but I don't hold that against her. I really believe that she would be more successful in purchasing directly from Coach by calling up customer service and asking if they have anymore of these lying around so that she could carefully comb over the bag and easily return it to her local store if it is not up to her standards (although her comments about not be willing to pay $150 for a $400 bag are indicitive of her attitude toward Coach's pricing).
Being a Coach collector I bought a few bags off of Ebay that were either significantly not as described or in one case fake. In all cases a pleasant, understanding, and respectful attitude toward the seller easily solved the problem.