So, so sad: 4 doctors, 2 pilots dead after trying to deliver organs


Jan 29, 2006
Maybe you have heard about this.

6 (4 doctors, 2 pilots) people in a medical team died trying to deliver organs to a long-time smoker who needed a double-lung transplant. Their plane suffered mechanical failure shortly after take-off and plunged into Lake Michigan. Now this man is getting a second set of lungs.

I wonder how many people die each year from diseases not related to smoking because a new set of lungs didn't reach them in time.


A patient whose double lung transplant operation was stopped after a plane carrying donor organs crashed into Lake Michigan has received a second set of lungs, doctors announced Friday.

The 50-year-old Michigan man, whose name wasn't released at his family's request, was in critical condition at a University of Michigan Health System hospital after the more than seven-hour surgery ended early Thursday, the health system said.

"We are relieved that we were able to do this transplant and give this man another chance for life," Dr. Jeffrey Punch, director of the Division of Transplantation at University of Michigan, said in a statement. "Our friends that died in the crash would have wanted us to go on with our work."

The patient already was prepped for surgery, with his chest cut open and his lungs exposed to the air in the operating room, when the plane crashed, killing six members of a Survival Flight team.

Officials learned late Tuesday that another set of donor organs was available.
"If he had not received a transplant in a timely fashion he would have died," said Dr. Andrew C. Chang, one of two doctors who led the surgical team.
The patient has not been told of the crash. "I'll tell him more when he can handle it," Chang said.

Chang said the man's condition is "significantly improved."

The patient, a longtime smoker, needed the transplant because of a condition called chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder, the health system said. He had been on the waiting list for a double lung transplant since November.

The patient's family, in a statement released by the health system, said it was devastated and heartbroken for the families of the six team members who died in the crash.

The new organs were transported by chartered plane from an undisclosed donor hospital to Willow Run Airport near Ypsilanti, where a transplant donation specialist met the plane and carried the organs to the hospital on a Survival Flight helicopter.

"It is magnificent that this team has continued the work of our team that we lost," Dr. Robert Kelch, the health system's chief executive, said in an e-mail Friday to the health system's employees.

He noted that members of the transplant team continued to work as they dealt with the loss of their colleagues.

"This wonderful news doesn't in any way relieve the acute pain we are feeling at the loss of our dedicated Survival Flight crew," he said.

Killed in Monday's crash near Milwaukee were cardiac surgeon Dr. Martinus Spoor, transplant donation specialist Richard Chenault II, Dr. David Ashburn, a physician-in-training in pediatric cardiothoracic surgery, transplant donation specialist Richard LaPensee and pilots Dennis Hoyes and Bill Serra.


Feb 5, 2006
They crashed in my city, it has been allover the news here. They were from Michigan and in town to pick up the organs from a local hospital.

{waves} to Japster!

Very sad to see the news this week. It was all over the local news.

Yes, Wisconsin has one of the best organ transplant networks in the country. (It was one of Tommy Thompson's pet projects)

One of the most important things in transplant success is the time it takes to transplant: the faster the better. I know Wisconsin takes a lot of flak sometimes for "hoarding" organs (for lack of a better word). But sometimes it makes no sense to literally transport organs for several hours. The success rate falls dramatically the longer the organ is out of a living body.

Just curious, how many states out there have organ donor programs? Here in Wisconsin you get a sticker put on/in your driver's license.