So similar, but which one?!

[CartierLVer]

Hello TPF members,

Without looking at the brand and being bias towards, which of the two would you choose? TIA

Hermes:

https://www.hermes.com/us/en/product/heure-h-watch-30.5x30.5mm-W054131WW00/

Cartier:

https://www.cartier.com/en-us/watches/mens-watches/santos-de-cartier-watch-CRWSSA0037.html

 

[lonelyphoton]

To my eye, the lines look cleaner and more classic on the watch with the steel band (Santos). It also looks more comfortable with no sharp edges!

 

[MaggyH]

I've had the Hermes and sold it as never really reached for it, so I vote Santos

 

[A1aGypsy]

Definitely the Cartier. That H feels too in your face to me.

 

[Caspin22]

My husband saw that H watch in the boutique in Vegas last month and he loves it! But between the two, I personally prefer the look of the Cartier, so that's what I voted for.