Drum roll...for both $1200!!!
My DH's friend owns a pawn shop and we stopped in (DH likes to buy silver coins) when we are in town. I was actually going to wait in the car but it is not in the best area. So, I went in and looked around. I did not see any jewels that really caught my eye and told him my wish list (which was the enchant diamond key). He then goes into the safe and pulls out two keys! He said they were in the safe for years! We were near casinos and I felt like I hit the jackpot!
Even though DH totally trusts him 110%, I did go to T's to check them out. I told him to be on the lookout for a rose gold one to complete the set.