It is definitely a matter of personal choice... When I re-entered the world of LV, I began by purchasing all of the accessories that I thought I'd ever want and need, brand new from LV. As time went by I purchased a couple of big bags, brand new too. Then I got into the rare/discontinued accessories-got those on ebay and so on with my bags that I didn't purchase brand new. I absolutely love having all of the accessories I could ever want. Now if something comes out new that I really, really like it's no big deal to just add it to my vast accessories collection. Good luck with your decision.