Skinny Tote or Edie Turnlock?

Valkrie

O.G.
Jun 17, 2007
535
281
I desprately need some opinions. I ordered the 1941 Skinny Tote in smoke/cornflower since it was half off. I also ordered from Macy's Edie turnlock in navy. I can't decide which one to keep. I love the glove tanned leather & leather lining in the Skinny Tote and I also love the gunmetal hardware on Edie. Edie is lighter too. Any opinions ?
 
Jan 13, 2015
13,645
10,518
In the Paddock
Only seen Edie(actually own the smaller 28 version) but i adore the glove tanned leather pieces much more(own a few there too, just not the skinny tote)

However at the days end it's about what will you actually use most? if it's only eye candy, it's not much use to you.
 
Jul 23, 2006
10,522
2,852
I like the Edie as more of an everyday bag. The tote seems better suited for work although, you could use it everyday.
 

Hobbsy

Sofa King Banned
Apr 11, 2015
7,999
8,240
I have the Skinny tote and it's a great bag! The smoke color is beautiful, the inside is smooth leather, not heavy. ...I love it! I have an Edie 31 and I like that bag also.

I call it collecting!