Should I keep this yellow Birkin?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

ladybug333

Member
May 6, 2019
194
849
I’ve only recently started to dive into the world of Hermès, and have fallen fast and hard for the Birkin and Kelly (until now, Chanel has been my brand of choice). I find the colorful Hermès bags to be such an absolute delight, and I imagine a collection of many different colorful bags in the future (at the moment I have 5-6 black Chanel bags and one red one, so I feel good about my neutrals and really want more colorful bags in my collections).

I’m still not sure if I’m interested in the Hermes process (mainly bc I don’t love their other items) so I’ve been looking into reseller sites (and also happen to be going to Paris next month where I’ll try my luck). A color I’ve been lusting after is yellow and recently purchased an Epsom Soleil Birkin 30 in nearly excellent condition. It’s beautiful!! Perfect shade of yellow for me and I love the size and how happy the color is! In even better condition than I expected, too! This would be my first Hermès bag.

But now that I have it (and have two days to decide if I want to keep it), I’m nervous! Primarily for the possible reactions I’d receive? I live in LA, so I don’t feel like this bag is too out of the ordinary here, but it still definitely screams “status” to people familiar with it. Personally, I love luxurious things, but tend to buy things that are more understated so that people who aren’t into this world wouldn’t know the difference. But there’s also a BIG part of me who is starting to say, “screw it” and who is owning her love of luxury instead of worrying about pleasing people with safer fashion choices. But I think I’d especially feel uncomfortable wearing this bag around family and some friends who can’t afford things like this — especially the Birkin since it’s more recognizable. I like the Kelly because it feels like people are less familiar with it.

Then there’s the flip side: cost. I feel like bags are a slippery slope for me — I love them! And because I can technically afford them without a problem, I’m worried I’ll end up buying tons of these bags over the next year! And I have a sense of guilt that I should’ve invested that money instead in stocks/real estate. Do you ever have that fear, that you technically have the money for these purchases, but that spending $25-50k/year on bags is money that would be much better spent elsewhere? Have any of you ever felt complete after getting everything you’ve been pining after, or does the desire for new bags ever really end?

I hope none of this comes off the wrong way. :heart: Genuinely just wavering back and forth about this bag — it’s gorgeous, I love the color, and the craftsmanship and history of it are special to me. Would love to hear from others who may have felt the same way before investing in Hermes bags and how it turned out for you. :smile:

652A5B3B-8A3F-48D9-981C-57D0430AF758.jpeg 5A71FBA2-0461-4344-B267-6A96EAD36380.jpeg
 
Hello. Congrats for scoring your first B ( i assume). H bags are way too costly for one to have "reservations". If you feel uncomfortable wearing it, be it the colour or style - REHOME. I understand your worries about others being judgemental of H, my 2 cents - it's your hard earned money and you have the absolute right to enjoy the finer things in life. Over the years of H collection, i refuse to succumb such sacarsm ( be it from family or friends) about my ownership of the brand simply because i LOVE and appreciate the craftmanship of H. Timeless and classic pieces that i can pass on to my daughters. Wishing you the best of luck in deciding.
 
It's a beautiful bag! I love the color. You need to feel comfortable wearing it whenever you want or you won't get your money's worth. All those questions you ask are questions I ask myself and I live in a much less fashionable community than you. My daughter once told me I shouldn't buy a purse that cost more than her car. You carry Chanel, which isn't under the radar either. I think more people can identify Chanel than Hermes. As far as investing the money instead, it depends on how much money you need. If you are already investing a reasonable portion of your income, then I don't think it is a problem. If you are spending everything you make without setting anything aside, then I think that is a mistake. I think some people eventually feel complete or the desire for bags goes away. That could take a very long time though.
 
It's a beautiful bag! I love the color. You need to feel comfortable wearing it whenever you want or you won't get your money's worth. All those questions you ask are questions I ask myself and I live in a much less fashionable community than you. My daughter once told me I shouldn't buy a purse that cost more than her car. You carry Chanel, which isn't under the radar either. I think more people can identify Chanel than Hermes. As far as investing the money instead, it depends on how much money you need. If you are already investing a reasonable portion of your income, then I don't think it is a problem. If you are spending everything you make without setting anything aside, then I think that is a mistake. I think some people eventually feel complete or the desire for bags goes away. That could take a very long time though.
Thank you for the response! Totally agree. And I feel like it's really just about being unapologetic about the things we love instead of compromising who we are.

That's true about more people being able to recognize Chanel over Hermes. I used to be afraid to buy Chanel bags for the same reason (especially ones that had the classic CC lock on them), but now I embrace them and LOVE wearing them.

As for money, I have a healthy savings and already invest quite a bit into other avenues (stocks, real estate, etc). Financially, I am perfectly fine. So I think my fears in this area are more about the internal guilt that says, "It's responsible to invest money, and not responsible to spend $10k+ on a purse," even if that's not true. Old programming to let go of, right?
 
Gosh, that is gorgeous. I love the color. I have never particularly been interested in H bags... until now! You wear it well.

I will never be able to spend that kind of money on a bag, but good for you that you can! If you can be comfortable using your Birkin, I vote keep it.

I used to feel awkward about the number of H scarves I have (probably 40), as a colleague used to comment each time I wore one. (I live somewhere off the fashion grid, and no one else registered what they are beyond being a nice scarf.) But I love them and have gotten past that after wearing them often.

Good luck with your decision.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ladybug333
Personally I love H colors much more than the neutrals. I feel like all brands do neutrals well, but H kicks ass with their gorgeous colors! You can buy a neutral in any brand, every brand. But the colors in H are sooooo special. I LOVE your yellow but YOU have to LOVE IT! These bags are far too expensive to have reservations.
 
Even if you are financially fine, there really is no justification for spending $10k on a purse because there is always better utility for the money (for example, investing in financial instruments, giving the money to charity, saving for your children’s college fund). But that is besides the point. In life it is okay to succumb to wants, be it $10 wants or $10k wants, according to your financial ability. Your birkin is so lovely - the colour is happy in fact - and you can afford it, so just enjoy it!
 
Top