I have the black medium Gaucho and I love it. I use it for every day and I don't care what I'm wearing, it could be a white dress or jeans. As it is summer here it probably is a bit heavy for my summer clothes but I paid a lot for this baby and I am going to get a lot of use out of her.
By the way I started using it Christmas Day and it looks as fab as the day I bought her..
OMG no its horrible, just send it to me instead, honestly both bags look good on u, its just a matter of what u feel comfortable with as your carrying it.
I think both look good on you. I don't have a rebelle so I can't say how good it is but I have a gaucho for a year now. I use it daily for work and I'm really happy with it, plus it's aging quite well, because it's designed to look vintage, it ages better than other bags.
So, I think you keep whichever bag you're most comfortable with.
That's great to hear it is ageing well, I guess I will have mine for a long time. And my daughter is almost 17 and she doesn't mind that I am now in a bag buying faze. More to borrow.
I sent the gaucho back last week. Perhaps in the future a medium gaucho would work for me; the double was too large and I just couldn't see myself using it enough to justify the pricetag. Better to send it back to NM.com unused and let someone else enjoy it.