Should I exchange?

[margaritas]

So I bought a pair of Aldo heels today. But now that I'm trying them on at home, I realise they are a little too big as they slip off my feet at times. It's about a finger's width too big. I'm a size 37.5 but I bought size 38. Since Aldo does not carry half-sizes, should I exchange them for size 37 instead? Well, I briefly tried on the display piece which was a 37 but I can't quite squeeze my foot in. However, I really hate that the 38s slip off so do you think I should bear the pain and go with 37?

I combed through the forum and I read that perhaps having inserts in the shoes will do. I don't mind this option but I'm afraid it won't do in the long run if the shoes stretch. Mine's patent leather by the way. So ladies, what should I do? Exchange or just buy inserts?

 

[shop-a-holic!]

what I usually do is..I would get tip toe from foot petals(Nordstroms carry them) and insert them to make the shoes feel a little tighter....once the shoes stretch a little and my heels start to slip off, then I get heel pads.....

you know there are sometimes shoes that you absolutely wanna get but are sold out in your size....that's when I use the trick of adding foot petals!

 

[wantmore]

Do you really love the shoes that you can't live without it? If so, then buy the inserts. To me, I'd rather have inserts than be in pain.

 

[margaritas]

I went back today and thank god they gave me inserts! Now it fits better but a tad tight! I'm happy though. Thanks anyway for you ladies' input!