Seeking recs for a dark DARK brown cream eyeshadow, either pot or stick

[e_nmn_m]

Can anyone recommend a dark brown cream eyeshadow, either in a pot or stick form? I mean DARK brown, like an espresso color. It's ok if it's browner if worn smudged and sheer, but when used as a liner it should be dark.

I like MUFE aqua stick in 4E, but everyone tells me that it is gray and not dark ashy brown.

 

[jiffer]

Can anyone recommend a dark brown cream eyeshadow, either in a pot or stick form? I mean DARK brown, like an espresso color. It's ok if it's browner if worn smudged and sheer, but when used as a liner it should be dark.

I like MUFE aqua stick in 4E, but everyone tells me that it is gray and not dark ashy brown.

Mac paint pots has a dark brown. Its constructivist

 

[DC-Cutie]

Bobbi brown gel liner in clavier or espresso. Can be worn as shadow (great for smokey eyes) and still looks intense as a liner.

 

[italian1224]

Bobbie brown mahogany or mac e/s in mystery is nice

 

[e_nmn_m]

I didn't know the BB gel eyeliner could be worn as a shadow. I'll have to consider that one!

I tried on Lancome's 24H cream E/S in Extreme Espresso, and while I loved the color and wear-time, thought it was a bit crumbly. But maybe because I used the tester? Along the same lines, L'oreal makes one in Cocoa, but that looks a bit glittery and the last time I tried one of those pots, thought it was glittery AND crumbly. (I wonder if a damp brush would overcome the crumbly problem?)

 

[Cait]

NARS Ponderosa, Maybelline Rich Mahogany Color Tattoo.

 

[beauxgoris]

I know you said creme - but nars mekong is the darkest brown I've ever seen.