Same print differnt style...

wifeyb

wallet whore
O.G.
Aug 20, 2006
4,545
20
38
Indianapolis, IN
so im trying to expand my coach collection and get differnt styles and materials.....i currently have a black on black sig madeline....but i would love a black on black sig zoe....do you thin that is a waste? or too similar? im also going to be getting a green patent zoe.....i really wanted the berry zoe, but i have the magenta pleated ergo, and i felt they were too close in color, hints why im stuck on the black and black sig zoe....TIA ladies!!!! :sunnies
 

jeh3v

RM Love
O.G.
Jun 5, 2008
15,732
1
Nashville, TN
I personally think if you are craving variety, you should stick to something different because two black sig. bags are too similar, KWIM?
 
Dec 17, 2008
2,803
79
I think buying two black on black sig bags of different styles would be like buying a black Zoe and a black Sabrina. They may be the same color but the styles are not the same which makes each one different. If you like it, buy it.
 

vtfroggie

>.<
O.G.
May 14, 2008
6,118
14
The land of Mary
I kind of agree with Jeh3v, but on the other hand black is a neutral color and I think the style of these 2 bags is different enough that you could get away with having both in your collection.
Ultimately, I think I'd go with the green zoe and then pick one up in another color (not black sig or berry).
 

lizmil

O.G.
Dec 30, 2007
5,533
327
I think you should get what you like. The Zoe & the Madeline are so different in shape they don't seem like duplicates. I have the Parker hippie in black/black signature. I like the black/black combo.
 

sassypursefreak

Team Eric
Aug 12, 2007
586
0
44
You mention wanting the Berry patent, and the black/black siggy- what if you kind of combined it and went with the aubergine sig? It will be beautiful for fall/winter, it's totally different from the other items you list that you own. Otherwise, I wouldn't hesitate to own two black/black siggy items if one was Madeline and the other is Zoe, because i view Madeline as the more structured/classic type bag and the Zoe isn't. Good luck deciding!
 

wifeyb

wallet whore
O.G.
Aug 20, 2006
4,545
20
38
Indianapolis, IN
sassy! i see you got my new HG the green zoe! lol. isnt the aubergine sig, khaki sig on the main part? and a colored trim? ive seen that and i dont care for it too much...unless im thinking of something else! lol and i forgot im wanting a peyton! lol in the green pearlized, so would the green zoe too be weird? oh bother....all the choices and colors!
 

shy*violet

I heart PINK!
Mar 9, 2008
1,297
0
For me, that would be a lost cause if you're really trying to go into different colors/prints/styles.