So I just came back from my dermatologist and she said anything that has non-comedogenic should be fine. When I told her that I broke out when I used Bare Minerals she was confused and speechless. I'm somewhat doubting her expertise on acne skin (mainly cause shes pushing really hard for antibotics... and for me I'm not comfortable with putting pills in my body to get rid of the one or two deep ones that now exist... since the creams she gave me work great in getting rid of everything else)... but I am glad that the perscriptions that she has given me have been working really well!!
I'm down to two remaining acne scars (currently healing) and my forehead is more or less clear! I've done alot of reading in this forum and other acne related forums, and I think I will give mineral make up another chance. Whenever I go to the Bare Minerals boutique they cake it on me... and I think thats why I break out so much. They layer and layer different things on my skin.. (even my fiance thinks that I look cakey and he doesn't know a thing about makeup).
I have also been watching alot of youtube makeup tutorials and the way I see people use mineral makeup is very sparingly. I also might try ones thats talc and mica free.
winnie83 - let me know how it works out for you? I've tried so many foreign brands through out the years... i'm also asian so.. whenever we have family reunions.. my family would always comment on my acne... i'm the odd one out in the family who never grew out of it... so they always keep recommending creams and sets... I've tried expensive sets from hawaii... japan... australia... korea... I've even tried the somewhat cheaper solutions like papaya soap and at the time we had the FaceShop (I believe its korean?).. my roommate at the time swore by it.. nothing worked for me... =*(... I gave up for a good 3 years on my skin and just let it be.. I literally just used a gentle cleanser.. and moisterizer on dry parts of my skin.. no make up to cover up my skin... still no improvement... in fact.. it got worse.. and my face started to hurt (it hurt like I had a ton of bruises on my face) and thats why i went to the dermo.. I'm so happy atm! ^__^
She's not pushing the antibiotics b/c she's not an expert in her field; you HAVE to treat acne from the inside out, and most methods of treatment begin with a regimen of strong antibiotics. But then again, you say you have one or two deep pimples.... so maybe it's not textbook acne after all.
I'm a firm believer in not trying too hard to get your skin to do what it wants to do. And you HAVE to give yourself TIME for treatments to work. Just switching from one expensive brand to another is going to empty your wallet and cause more distress. I was a longtime acne sufferer, and went through everything you are saying, but what I've FINALLY (!!!!) found is that Cetaphil cleanser (the daily foaming one, not the gently lotion-like one) and lotion are my Holy Grail skincare products. I exfoliate maybe once a week (it sounds bad, but my skin just does not need it) and I use the Mint Julep Mask by Queen Helene a couple of times a week. Mainly I use it whenever I'm in my bedroom folding laundry or watching late night tv.
Another thing that some cynics like to hate on, but it works for me is water. I'm currently in my 4th month of pregnancy, and I've been averaging about 100 ounces a day..... and while all my friends are complaining about cystic acne due to pregnancy hormones, mine is crystal clear. (Except for a few blackheads on my chin, but I just ordered the Clarisonic to take care of those!)
Since I have been seeing my dermatologist, she has recommended Clinique. Now, I know it's not the "trendy" makeup or the stuff that is in pretty cases, but I've been using it for 15 years now (I've cheated but ALWAYS have gone back) and it's the only thing that works. In fact, I just saw my dermatologist the other day and she STILL sings the praises of Clinique and Cetaphil.... I thought to myself "Why didn't I listen about the Cetaphil when I was 13??" ..... I would have saved a lot of money!
Best of luck -- but remember, use gentle products, not harsh and give yourself TIME to see results. (As in, 4-6 weeks). Be patient!