Rose Dragee Birkin or Kelly

baghag21

O.G.
Jan 7, 2006
1,081
740
Hi ALL...have recently started craving for a Rose Dragee bag after initial impartiality with the colour. Was going to go for a 30cm Birkin after sighting it on a lady who looked fantastic with it (just like Vermillion).:drool: Saw RD Kellys in 25cm & 28cm. Didn't think much of them till my local store manager mentioned that she felt RD looked better in a Kelly. At the same time, I would like to get a 28cm Kelly as well (was thinking Etoupe of Blue Jean). Now I'm totally undecided...I was so sure of a RD 30cm Birkin then am conflicted with thoughts of a 28cm Kelly.:confused1:

You wonderful TPFers will be the best source of advice. Please spill!!!:P
 

princessfrog

so you Kelly?
Nov 22, 2006
3,157
7
I personally like RD on a kelly. That color look so delicate and Kelly is so ladylike that personally I think it suits it to a "T".
I prefer Birkins to be colorful with abit of ompf! I feel it's more causal and playful bag :flowers:
 

CobaltBlu

Butterfly Wrangler
Moderator
O.G.
Oct 20, 2006
40,194
2,537
OK, this is not what you asked, but I saw a massai in RD and I absolutely loved it. And I was only an admirer from afar of the massai, I did not see myself wearing it...but my SA made me try it, and WOWZA!!! it was awesome in RD.

My life has too many dogs, goats, horses, pens, and teenagers for RD, but that was a really incredibly lovely bag....

and something i had not thought of before, so wanted to share that.....RD is lovely!!!!!

As I said, I know you were asking about B/K RD, but I wanted to throw that out there, because it was a total surprise to me to see how lovely the Massai was in RD!:heart:
 
Apr 21, 2007
832
28
Northern VA
I'm RD obsessed. My personal opinion is after seeing both a 25 Kelly and 35 flat Kelly in RD it looks too "going to a tea party" (this is not a bad thing). I couldn't see wearing either of them with jeans or part of a professional wardrobe. I like it in Lindy, Birkin, Trim, or Massai because the RD is feminine, while the bag shape makes it laid back. In the case of the Birkin in RD it would be, for me, versatile.
 

Pepper

Raisinette
Authenticator
O.G.
Oct 12, 2006
6,102
59
I love RD in principle but the reality of it gives me angina. So, if I were to do it, I would do it in a non-workhorse bag. A 28 Kelly if I had to choose between a Kelly or Birkin. My Birkins take too much of a beating (but I use them as totes as opposed to a true handbag).
Personally I think RD in swift looks best in the Lindy. Something about the shape, the leather's hand, and the color really grabs me. Practicality issues aside...
 
Feb 17, 2007
3,165
154
I love it in the lindy. The way it drapes is so pretty. Also, it isn't going to show scratches as easily, being the shape. Love the color with brown!
 

PGN

O.G.
Feb 5, 2006
1,714
1
I am more of a kelly girl so my first impulse is to say kelly....but I happened to someone carrying a RD birkin last week and I just about fainted! It took my breath away and I haven't stopped thinking about it!
 

kim_mac

O.G.
Feb 27, 2007
2,117
130
kelly - delicate, feminine and surprisingly i think it would look extra special with GHW.
 

baghag21

O.G.
Jan 7, 2006
1,081
740
Thanks for all your feedback! Looks like support is greater for the Kelly, with the Lindy next and Birkin last. Perhaps this is due to RD being perceived as a TLC-colour more appreciated on the refined Kelly. A Birkin seems to be the "workhorse" more befitting a hardier colour. :yes:

Seems that RD is a colour that is more attractive when seen IRL, especially on the arms of others. That's how my love affair with RD began :girlsigh:
 

baghag21

O.G.
Jan 7, 2006
1,081
740
kelly - delicate, feminine and surprisingly i think it would look extra special with GHW.
You are right!!!:yes: GHW would lift up the pallor of the RD. GHW on RD may have to be a special order. All the RD Ks or Bs I've seen thus far have been with palladium.
 

pigleto972001

Guh.
O.G.
Oct 6, 2006
7,937
10,252
i say kelly, i LOVE RD but the thought of it in a birkin would give me fits...i'd be so worried about getting it dirty by banging it into the walls or something. i'd be much less likely to mess up a kelly (but that's just me, i'm clumsy).

either way, you can't go wrong with the color!
 

bagluv

Always A Princess
O.G.
Mar 15, 2006
7,010
2
Both:nuts:

I'd Love RD For A Kelly.....But, It's Beyond Gorgous For A Birkin:heart::heart::heart:
 

Berlyn

<3 H
May 24, 2007
1,333
0
I like the RD birkin in 30. I've seen it in person and think its so cute!!!!!!