Personally, get what you think looks best on you and what makes your heart sing! I got a YG Daytona last year, and even though RG seemed like the more trendy choice, the RG Daytona just didn't look right on me. For Christmas, DH got me a RG Day-Date, and the RG is some of the most beautiful I've ever seen. I used to think no one could beat Cartier's RG, but reading about fading issues scared me. Those issues are non-existent with Rolex' RG. I am in love with my new RG Rolex! If you have a chance, go try on the watch you want in both golds and see which you prefer. If that's not possible, at least try on any YG and any RG Rolex to see which color you prefer on you. GL with your decision! The good news is, no matter what you choose, you know it's going to be stunning!