Review: S/S 21 Garden Collection: Small Zip Around Wallet With Embroidered Radish Motif

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

myskatten

Member
Apr 14, 2021
29
88
Info about the item
I bough this wallet from the (Japanese) Coach website last week for 35.200円. The name of the listing is (translated to English) “New Small Zip Around Wallet With Embroidered Radish Motif”. The wallet came with free shipping and free gift wrapping (since it’s was an early birthday gift to myself I gift wrapped it). It took around 3 workdays from order to the package was delivered.

The wallet is made of polished pebbled leather. It’s fully lined with burgundy finer grained leather and fabric for the bill pocket in the back. Hardware is Coach signature brass hardware.

The wallet have one bill pocket, one small zip pocket for coins, 4 card slots and 2 additional slip pockets (where you can add additional cards). The measurements on the website is listed as: length 9.5cm x width 11.5cm x depth 2cm, which seems accurate.

First impression
The wallet was a bit bigger than I imagined. I’m not sure if it’s the print that make it look smaller on the website, but I was surprised. However, I do like the size.

The right side card pockets (placed over the coin pocket) are tighter and also more narrow than the left ones. With coins filled I think it will be almost impossible to use the left slip pocket. However, this is ok for me.

Quality
The quality looks good. All the stitches are straight and even. The glancing looks great. I know Coach products are machine stitched but even so it’s hard to see where the tread is fastened (this is a pet peeve of mine if I see where the machine stitches have been layered up to fastened the thread).

The embroidery itself are also machine stitched, however it looks very even and good. There is a nice blending of colors and they have even used different thickness of the thread to create some texture which I appreciate. The small “Coach” logo next to the radish looks like it’s heat stamped in.

The leather is smooth and nice and evenly grained. I’m not sure what the dying process is like at Coach but my guess is that the leather is dyed on top rather then dyed trough. I guess this because the color is externally even. Doing a scratch test with my nails on the wallet does not leave any mark so I think it will be very durable.

The inside leather might crack in the middle after long use since it’s gets bend so much. I would love to know other peoples experience with Coach wallets and the quality of the inside burgundy leather.

The zipper is very smooth and feels great. My only complained is that at the top of the zipper (image 5) the fabric will probably start fraying in the future. I will have to be careful with this part.

Usability
I think the wallet is great. I live in Japan where we still use a lot of cash so I’m happy that I can store all my coins, cards and bills in one place. The amount of card slots is perfect for me since I don’t carry that many.

The coin pouch is a bit tight so it might be hard to find the exact coin you are looking for. Also, the coin punch can not double up as an extra card slot since the zipper is not wide enough for a standard card.

I think the size is great but if you are looking for a mini wallet for a mini bag, maybe this might be too big.

The Good
It’s absolutely adorable! I love how I can keep all my money in one place. The quality is feels great for the price (it’s a fully lined leather wallet). I think the leather, especially the outside leather, feels very durable and scratch resistant. The embroidery does look good and even. The stitches and glancing looks perfect. The zipper is smooth. It’s a nice size in the hand. (Bonus points: it does, like I hoped, matches perfectly with my everyday bag from Tideway Japan.) No large logo (this is of course personal, but personal I don’t like logos).

The Bad
The fabric of where the zipper stops/ends does look like is has the risk of start fraying. The coin pocket is very snug and so is the card pockets on the right side. The slip pocket on the right side is for me unusable with coins inside (too snug).

Verdict
I’m so happy that I bought this wallet! I think it’s adorable and I look forward to use it many years to come. I hope that the leather will age beautiful and with age get a nice patina. I think this wallet suits my personality and my lifestyle great. This will be my only wallet and I do not plan to buy any other one. Since it’s brown I think will will looks good all year round (compared to black).

If you look for a wallet with the same specification and size I highly recommend it.

I do not recommend this wallet to someone who like mini wallets/card holders or someone who likes large wallets with a lot of card slots. If you like a compact walled that can carry all of you essentials this one is great.

695737B5-DF7A-46C6-A706-E6221BFCE50D.jpeg

4A04E286-5DA8-44D7-9F4D-523D7BF4B758.jpeg

0456FAF4-113E-4E31-8609-6BF3084765FA.jpeg

88EC7F98-51D8-4FA8-887E-C4E86F6A229D.jpeg

47D690DC-518E-4C85-A9A6-5EA48F0ED8FC.jpeg

E975CB7A-70A9-46AA-A0DC-8E279B70F0B9.jpeg

FD5DAC95-9ECA-4590-948E-7D769732D29A.jpeg

E3E2D0A3-B067-4955-B502-525D05638424.jpeg

4F583DA3-D0BB-40DB-8B07-CA9527284A2A.jpeg

6E4A4137-1CC6-44E9-A0C0-2B1EDD816676.jpeg
 
Info about the item
I bough this wallet from the (Japanese) Coach website last week for 35.200円. The name of the listing is (translated to English) “New Small Zip Around Wallet With Embroidered Radish Motif”. The wallet came with free shipping and free gift wrapping (since it’s was an early birthday gift to myself I gift wrapped it). It took around 3 workdays from order to the package was delivered.

The wallet is made of polished pebbled leather. It’s fully lined with burgundy finer grained leather and fabric for the bill pocket in the back. Hardware is Coach signature brass hardware.

The wallet have one bill pocket, one small zip pocket for coins, 4 card slots and 2 additional slip pockets (where you can add additional cards). The measurements on the website is listed as: length 9.5cm x width 11.5cm x depth 2cm, which seems accurate.

First impression
The wallet was a bit bigger than I imagined. I’m not sure if it’s the print that make it look smaller on the website, but I was surprised. However, I do like the size.

The right side card pockets (placed over the coin pocket) are tighter and also more narrow than the left ones. With coins filled I think it will be almost impossible to use the left slip pocket. However, this is ok for me.

Quality
The quality looks good. All the stitches are straight and even. The glancing looks great. I know Coach products are machine stitched but even so it’s hard to see where the tread is fastened (this is a pet peeve of mine if I see where the machine stitches have been layered up to fastened the thread).

The embroidery itself are also machine stitched, however it looks very even and good. There is a nice blending of colors and they have even used different thickness of the thread to create some texture which I appreciate. The small “Coach” logo next to the radish looks like it’s heat stamped in.

The leather is smooth and nice and evenly grained. I’m not sure what the dying process is like at Coach but my guess is that the leather is dyed on top rather then dyed trough. I guess this because the color is externally even. Doing a scratch test with my nails on the wallet does not leave any mark so I think it will be very durable.

The inside leather might crack in the middle after long use since it’s gets bend so much. I would love to know other peoples experience with Coach wallets and the quality of the inside burgundy leather.

The zipper is very smooth and feels great. My only complained is that at the top of the zipper (image 5) the fabric will probably start fraying in the future. I will have to be careful with this part.

Usability
I think the wallet is great. I live in Japan where we still use a lot of cash so I’m happy that I can store all my coins, cards and bills in one place. The amount of card slots is perfect for me since I don’t carry that many.

The coin pouch is a bit tight so it might be hard to find the exact coin you are looking for. Also, the coin punch can not double up as an extra card slot since the zipper is not wide enough for a standard card.

I think the size is great but if you are looking for a mini wallet for a mini bag, maybe this might be too big.

The Good
It’s absolutely adorable! I love how I can keep all my money in one place. The quality is feels great for the price (it’s a fully lined leather wallet). I think the leather, especially the outside leather, feels very durable and scratch resistant. The embroidery does look good and even. The stitches and glancing looks perfect. The zipper is smooth. It’s a nice size in the hand. (Bonus points: it does, like I hoped, matches perfectly with my everyday bag from Tideway Japan.) No large logo (this is of course personal, but personal I don’t like logos).

The Bad
The fabric of where the zipper stops/ends does look like is has the risk of start fraying. The coin pocket is very snug and so is the card pockets on the right side. The slip pocket on the right side is for me unusable with coins inside (too snug).

Verdict
I’m so happy that I bought this wallet! I think it’s adorable and I look forward to use it many years to come. I hope that the leather will age beautiful and with age get a nice patina. I think this wallet suits my personality and my lifestyle great. This will be my only wallet and I do not plan to buy any other one. Since it’s brown I think will will looks good all year round (compared to black).

If you look for a wallet with the same specification and size I highly recommend it.

I do not recommend this wallet to someone who like mini wallets/card holders or someone who likes large wallets with a lot of card slots. If you like a compact walled that can carry all of you essentials this one is great.

View attachment 5062171

View attachment 5062172

View attachment 5062173

View attachment 5062174

View attachment 5062175

View attachment 5062176

View attachment 5062177

View attachment 5062178

View attachment 5062180

View attachment 5062181
I think the print is adorable!
 
  • Like
Reactions: americandreaming
Great review, thank you for taking the time to do this! I look forward to an update;)

Thanks for taking the time to read the review and leave a comment!

I can give you and update: I’ve had the wallet for 1 month now. This is the only wallet I’ve been using and I’ve used it almost everyday.

There are no swatches or any type of wear (which I would except after only 1 month!). The leather feels very durable but still very supple and soft in the hand. It’s a very comfortable wallet.

I still stand by everything I initially said but I’ve noticed two things that is not optimal:

1. The opening to coin punch is quite small so it’s not always the easiest to find coins.

2. The main zipper around the wallet can scratch both my hand and/or bills when I taking out bills.

Even with this issues I’m still happy that I didn’t buy a three-fold wallet but instead bought a zip around. My previous experience with three-fold wallets is that the corners (because they are sharper) easily gets mark and scuffs. With this wallet there is really no shap edges that I think will be prone to scathing but I guess only time will tell.

However, if any of these two points is something you know is going to bother you, I would recommend looking for another wallet.

Are you interested in buying it yourself?
 
  • Like
Reactions: americandreaming
I think that's really pretty and I love the colors especially, but my first thought was "When there's nothing else that hasn't been done before, you can always embroider a radish!" :biggrin:
I understand your sentiments but you really can’t embroider leather without special equipment (and even if you had leather needles and the skills to do it you would have to disassemble the whole wallet since only want to embroider the top layer). But I would probably not buy the wallet “only” for the radish :smile: Since I was in the market for a new wallet of this type and happened to see it on Coach website I felt like it was perfect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: americandreaming
Totally unrelated, but where can I get that Tideway bag? It's super cute.
Tideway is a local Tokyo leather artisan brand. This is thier website: https://tideway.sanki-net.co.jp/ and the specific bag I won is called Hanen Shoulder (I think the color I won is coco): https://tideway.sanki-net.co.jp/item/613250

However, Tideway themselves do only ship inside Japan. If you're outside of Japan maybe Rakuten or Amazon offer international shipping.
Rakuten: https://item.rakuten.co.jp/clelia/t1603/
Amazon: https://www.amazon.co.jp/タイドウェイ-HAN...ments=p_4:TIDEWAY(タイドウェイ)&s=shoes&sr=1-2&th=1
 
Top