Review - New Independent Korean Guide/Interpreter

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

chocolateandsamoyeds

Sofa King Banned
Jul 10, 2023
105
97

Hi,

My PS journey isn't at its end yet and I intended to post a longer review when that happens. I stumbled upon the 2 threads (linked above) and I thought it would be immediately impactful if I introduced a new interpreter I've been using. This will be a slightly long read, proportionate to what I'm confident can be gained from it.

To provide context, I speak fluent Mandarin and typically don't need an interpreter because nowadays the trend is for the popular Korean clinics to hire Chinese speaking staff, large migrant supply and large Influx of revenue from very demanding Chinese clients looking for the Korean aesthetic (and not just medical skill, compared to say the more ethnically western countries).

That being said, there are a small subset of popular Korean clinics that only speak Korean. More importantly, I find it immensely helpful to have a local accompany me along the journey. I don't think explaining this is necessary but I'll outline a few reasons anyway:

1) A clinic's clientele is the same as an interpreter's. In the presence of an interpreter they are far more likely to be responsible about the things they say and hold themselves accountable. In such a saturated industry, word of mouth is the most powerful advertising/marketing tool
2) Pictures and words can only convey so much. To be able to communicate in a contextually accurate and culturally appropriate manner demands significantly more than just being fluent in the language. Being a local and making a genuine effort to understand what your client is looking for counts for a lot
3) In the event that you require advocacy beyond just translations, the fee you're paying for this person will likely be worth several times as insurance


The following points can be replaced by joining a community, mostly on Kkt right now. This may not be possible because of the restrictions being placed on foreign accounts. That being said, someone who's helping you because she is being paid is likely to exhibit a different level of enthusiasm compared to a person who's doing it out of goodwill

1) Being in a foreign setting and not speaking the local language is an additional source of stress that you don't need. Especially when you're an emotionally and physically vulnerable state
2) Having someone to answer your questions about preparing, how to research, etc brings you immediately up to speed with the entire process
3) The cosmetic surgery industry in Korea is highly competitive. A person who can share her experiences with various clinics can be helpful assuming she's objective and neutral

I've used 2 translators in the past. Ryan and Selena. The former is well known in this community and his wife does lymphatic massages which may be helpful for those are interested in lyposuction. This time, I decided to go with Selena (kkt ID: sjungh) because Ryan was on holiday and I didn't want to bother him too much, and Selena had a few reviews from the community on kkt. Here is mine.

I engaged Selena not only for clinic translations but also for other cosmetic translation services. She's lived, studied and worked abroad and charges transparently. I prefer this to the more mercenary approach adopted by others. She was able to convey my intent to the doctor with the help of visual aids. Having gone for more than 5 procedures now, I'm reasonably able to tell if the doctor doesn't get it, and she made sure to remind me of points discussed before which I later left out. She went further by furnishing me with her own observations about the consultation.

All in all I felt she treated me genuinely and not just a business product. For others, she's helped out with ordering food and delivery. The thing I appreciated the most about her and which is a big part of why I'm writing this is that I ran into a pretty tight situation this time and she remained with me throughout the few crucial hours.

The only thing is that she's only about half a year in. Personally I consider that a plus because it means she is far less likely to have any sort of pre established relationship with any clinic. In fact, she never suggested any clinic to me and only commented based on what happened during the specific consultations themselves. Another plus point that's more personal to me is that I find girls (especially those who are new to the job) in Korea to be more hardworking and zealous to prove themselves. And she shares the same skepticism about the popular English clinics like me

I'll definitely be using her again in future. Her kkt id is sjungh and if she asks just tell her you saw this thread on pf
 
Thanks for the introduction to a new translator! I have a deposit with Ryan, but actually recently someone mentioned in one of the kakao groups that he wasnt responding to messages like a couple of weeks ago which was a little troubling, especially after the whole Brian thing. Dont know if theyre correlated or he was just busy.|

How did you feel both experiences compared?
 
  • Like
Reactions: guy8989
Ryan was on holiday, that's why I went looking for someone else. I've used Brian (which I didn't mention in my first post since there are doubts about him a broker), Ryan and Selena. Brian is more experienced because he's been doing it for a long time, I used him specifically for a clinic that I had already decided upon (and had the prices down) that he was supposedly a broker at, so if they later on jacked up the prices I would know instantly something was up.

Selena is a blanker canvas because she's only half a year in. She won't make recommendations. but has been to all the popular foreigner clinics I've asked her about + the popular local ones which I decided to visit even without English reviews. She can share both her positive and negative experiences with the clinics, though her second hand surgical related experiences is more limited (for now). For me the more surprising thing was when I potentially needed immediate surgery she was calm, helped reschedule everything on the spot with the large amount information I fed to her in a short period of time. I had just landed and this was a new discovery for me

Ryan is a little smack in the middle for me. I'm continuing with Selena in part because of the practical reason that she's just started and I feel she has a vested interest and enthusiasm in putting in much more effort in doing well and establishing a client base for referrals. Especially since personality wise she's more skeptical of the hospitals and friend-like to us vs some of the translators whom I felt wanted to keep a proper business relationship with the hospitals
 
Hey so following this post I immediately went ahead and hired selena for my friend’s and I plastic surgery consultation and treatments in Seoul.

It was the first time for both of us to undergo any kind of surgery and we were really picky about the result we wanted to get and about finding the right clinic/surgeon for us. In total Selena accompanied us to maybe 5-6 different clinics on different days, and then also accompanied us on surgery days and some follow-ups. In all honesty, it was not cheap but it was the best decision we could have made to hire her. She proved to be efficient and very accurate in translating our idea to the clinics, helping us book different appointments, asking remainder questions we hadn’t thought about during the consultations. She was very flexible with us and even changed her schedule to be able to accommodate a last minute appointment we had made.

She is transparent in her pricing and acts more like a friend when communicating with the clinics, you definitely feel that she is on your side. Above and beyond that, it was also reassuring to have someone knowledgeable about the procedures and explain to you the next steps and look out for you.

My friend and I both agreed that even though we had each other, working with Selena allowed us to have an even greater plastic surgery experience and achieve the aesthetic result that we wanted.
 
Does Selena help to bargain prices down close to local pricing? I believe Ryan does that which makes him valuable as a translator.

Because sometime how much your translator helped your bargain can well cover the cost of hiring them overall
 
Top