Here are a couple more shots...a close up of the grain and a comparison vs. a couple other caviar items I own.
My first reaction when I opened the box (aside from questioning why it was packaged in a white dust bag reserved for Classic Flaps and Reissues and not the typical black drawstring dust bag lol) was that I LOVE the color! It is the perfect shade of tan/camel for my wardrobe and exactly what I was hoping for! Not too yellow, not too dark. So color is spot on.
Then there is the finish...which as others have noted is more matte than my other caviar pieces, but it still has a bit of a sheen to it. In paint terms (from most matte to most shiny as follows: Flat, Matte, Eggshell, Satin, Semi-Gloss and Hi-Gloss) the finish would be comparable to Eggshell, possibly Satin. Now I could see how this might not be ideal for those wanting the bag in black or red (depending on the look you are going for), but in the camel, it is perfect for me since I was looking for a casual bag and anything too shiny make it more dressy, IMO.
Quality...hard to say. Everything lines up nicely and the stitching looks good. The quilts are a bit flatter than my other caviar items, but I'm not sure that is a quality issue...more of a style difference. I have 3 other boys, but one is goat and two are calf, so its hard to compare. This bag is definitely softer than the goat boy, because that thing is a like a tank, but is probably about as soft as the calf boys (based on pinching the bottom and bending the flap). I did notice that the clasp is a bit tougher to snap closed on this boy vs. my others, but I believe that is due to the ruthenium hardware vs. the shiny finish of my other three.
As happy as I am with the bag overall, I am having trouble falling in love with it due to all the negative reviews. So I am going to sit on it for a couple days and see how I feel. I have turned down a lot of other beige and tan bags offered to me by various SAs holding out for this exact bag and in all honesty, had I not read the negative reviews, it would probably have been love at first sight. But since I truly appreciate this forum and everyone's contributions and I value the opinions of the other TPFers, I want to take some time to consider it. If it were only a matter of style, I wouldn't bother since many people have differences of opinions there...but I want to make sure I am satisfied with the quality and durability of the bag.