Returns/Exchange Process on Defective Bag (heartbreaking/stressful situation)

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

lauralizette

Member
Aug 29, 2020
22
17
Hello!

I was wondering if I could get some advice on this matter (apologies in advance as this is gonna be a long one).

I purchased the Gucci Soho Disco Bag back on Thanksgiving via their website, it was intended as a Christmas gift. I picked up the package on 12/2 at FedEx and opened the outer shipping box to find the bag wrapped beautifully on its box and ribbon. Since I wanted the recipient to open it first, I left it as is. However, I ended up pitching in with family to get a much larger Christmas gift for this person. As such, I kept the gift to give to them on 1/4 for their birthday.

Fast forward to 1/4, we opened the package up the evening of their birthday. After removing the plastic coverings and tags so that the individual could inspect/try on the bag we immediately noticed some minor (but heartbreaking) issues including:

- What appears to be a hole in the bottom stitching of the double G’s and visible excess glue
- A scratch/lifted leather almost invisible to the naked eye but can be seen when light is shined on it or touched

I immediately told the person I would take care of it and get them a new bag and emailed Gucci straight away. I sent them photos and explained my situation. They finally responded on 1/8 and told me items were eligible for returns for up to 45 days after delivery date and to call client services for more info.

So I did just that, I spoke to a very lovely woman who told me not to worry and send the bag as is (without the plastic, though I sent back the tag inside the bag with all the original paperwork) and to mark the defective box on the returns form. I was told to use the shipping label given in the package but I decided to call them back for a new one, as it seemed to have expired.

This time, the woman I spoke to told me this would be an entirely different process than a return and sent me a overnight label as the bag would have to be looked at and evaluated. She also told me I would be able to exchange it if they accept it (when the last person said they did returns only and that I could place a new order as soon as my refunds processed).

Overall, this is the first time I’ve ever had any issues with Gucci in my many years of buying from them (both on their site or on other retailers). The conflicting info hasn’t made me feel at ease and I just sent off a $1299 (after tax) bag with conflicting guarantees of getting a return or replacement.

Has this ever happened to anyone? If so, how did Gucci ultimately resolve this? I did pay through PayPal so I know I might be covered there, but I wish Gucci made it simpler to fix this issue (after all, it was an expensive purchase, it wasn’t used AT ALL, and I have always maintained a good and honest relationship with the brand). I’d appreciate any help with this.

*I’ve included photos of the damaged areas including some lifted leather/glazing I noticed while taking photos of the bag prior to shipping back (for my records in case they ask for this).

54BF713E-7F75-4BFD-9028-615AB0CAAB55.jpeg

F5EA7BA7-99C3-46CB-AC44-4587CD7C3287.jpeg

2B8E1B3D-1D01-4803-9DEB-8B86898D80D7.jpeg

7F7053DD-7DF5-4B7A-A0AA-15DA132850EA.jpeg

AA063C87-FB75-44E1-A750-5EEBFBE2C81C.jpeg

E4F4F968-2001-45F1-9E19-86ED6E9217D7.jpeg

EDE9E5E0-6FD7-4246-9A2A-237818E78C71.jpeg

8E47157D-CEFD-43FF-A8BB-879677051DF2.jpeg
 
Just any update on my situation:

So I finally got my refund, but only after I got PayPal involved and after about three weeks of waiting for Gucci to respond. I ended up ordering a replacement only for it to arrive in almost perfect condition (had a hard spot on the top of the bag that looked like dried glue again). I ended up sending it back. All in all, it really wasn’t worth the frustration. I think the Gucci Soho Disco is definitely a modern classic and great closet staple if you have an older one or are able to inspect it in-store. Otherwise, I think I’ll be getting the new 1955 Horsebit crossbody in black leather as a suitable replacement gift.

This definitely isn’t typical of Gucci though, I just think the lower price point of the Soho line might account for the quality of the craftsmanship (though that’s definitely no excuse).
 
Top