Real or Photoshop????

The first two look real. I don't know about the bikini one. But the shadows look right, and I don't see any marked changes in skin tone that would indicate a cut and paste job. Frankly, I think parents will be more outraged by these photos than the girl's fans. These aren't so different from photos kids post of themselves all the time on places like MySpace or Facebook. They're a little naughty, but not that raunchy. She's got her clothes on, and there's no cleavage. Of course, if my daughter did that, I'd have a long, serious conversation with her, but perhaps unfortunately, these photos aren't so unusual. Maybe they should be, but they're not.