Here are my Tory Burch Stella booties I got from Nordstrom Rack last year for $80. The jeans are Mother, and also came from NR for $50.
The Stellas are available on eBay in several colors and sizes, and I highly recommend that you check them out. Despite their high heel these shoes are stable, well padded, and above all very comfortable. I've worn them out and about, and they're holding up beautifully well.
From left to right: Jimmy Choo, Isaac Mizrahi, and Prada
The Jimmy Choos were a gift from my BF about 6 years ago and they've held up beautifully over the years. I haven't started collecting designer shoes until fairly recently, but I think these were the catalyst that began my obsession. The Isaac Mizrahis were a gift from my mom, and the Pradas were a gift to myself from myself