Question about Andrea Brueckner

I am just under 5'4" - I have the saddle in black in the large size and it is just perfect for me. I can't imagine the medium being too big for you. -
 
Personally, I think it should be about your own comfort level. I am just barely five feet tall and I adore large bags. I say buy the bag you love and feel comfortable with. Don't worry about what other people might or might not think. :biggrin: