I like both. They are so different from each other. The Poppy is more neutral. The Kristin seems more summery. I love the textured detail on the Kristin. I am wondering if the Poppy leather is mottled looking like the pink and beige Poppys from last year, because I am not a fan of the distressed leather. It is funny because both of these bags were the ones I was drawn to in the Spring preview so I guess we have the same aesthetic. For me, even though the pink is beautiful, I don't think I would carry it. I would prefer a lighter, more subdued color.