well i guess i'm in the minority here, but i

my Rosewood.

I was choosing between the same two in amarante and chose the Rosewood. I wasn't too fond of the snaps on the Roxbury, and the Rosewood holds more than the Rox IMO. Plus, I realized I just liked the shape a lot. And that little pocket on the outside is useful ( i put my cell phone in it, so v. easy & quick access).