I just got back from the boutique. I made decision to go with green this time . I love color on the mini bag, esp this green makes my heart sing.I had the same dilemma and ended up with both. I originally wanted a navy one but couldn’t find navy in the US so I settled for black. Later on I was able to get the navy preloved. I contemplate selling one of them, but the black one has sentimental reasons so it’s still in my collection. I would get the one that sings to your heart.