Pls help me decide bw these!

[ZaiGk]

Hey everyone,
Pls help me decide bw an Oxblood Quinn Satchel and a Selena Sutton Satchel. I love both but have to buy just one anybody who owns either of these bags pls give your inputs so I can decide.
PS: both are on 40% off. Eagerly looking for your inputs. Thanks ❤️

 

[Alexa5]

I like the leather on the 2nd one more.

 

[Chicagogirl2005]

I think the Quinn is just such an elegant feminine bag, it barely compares with the Selena bag (which to me looks a bit old fashioned....). Plus the Quinn has such a practical interior organization. I prefer bags which are classy and practical, so I vote for the Quinn

 

[faintlymacabre]

I don't like the leather on the Quinn, nor how wide the base of the bag is (I'm imagining so much bottom corner damage).

 

[ZaiGk]

Thanks guys, they’re both such beautiful bags and colours that it’s getting tougher to decide. I appreciate all your views, so far the scales are tipping for Selena

 

[ZaiGk]

I don't like the leather on the Quinn, nor how wide the base of the bag is (I'm imagining so much bottom corner damage).

Yes that bottom corner damage is such a nightmare, thanks for pointing that out ❤️❤️

 

[ZaiGk]

I think the Quinn is just such an elegant feminine bag, it barely compares with the Selena bag (which to me looks a bit old fashioned....). Plus the Quinn has such a practical interior organization. I prefer bags which are classy and practical, so I vote for the Quinn

Yes, that feminine vintage charm of the Quinn attracted me to her, the colour is a plus too. Practical yes! I agree. I think you own a Quinn Chicagogirl2005, can you tell me how does is hold up for everyday use (I’m totally not the ‘occasional ‘IT’ bag girl, I use my precious bag for everyday use). Thanks much ❤️

 

[ZaiGk]

I like the leather on the 2nd one more.

The leather is glovetanned if I’m not wrong, it looks buttery-I wish they had more colour variety here in India though

 

[LaVisioneer]

I would not pay that much for a crossgrain leather bag (the Quinn). Nearly the same style called the Sierra (F57524) is made for the Coach outlets it's currently about $120. I like how durable crossgrain is but to me it feels like vinyl so it's not worth a high price tag.

I think the Selena bag on the other hand is glovetanned leather. That plus the pink color and bow charm would make me go for the Selena. I also think the Selena bag looks better when carried crossbody. But the glovetanned leather will probably require more care to keep it looking nice.

 

[AManIntoFashion]

The style of the first bag is very nice.

The color of the second bag is lovely, plus glove tanned leather seems to be rare now compared to cross grain leather .

(Again), just my opinion.

Enjoy whichever you buy!!!

 

[Jb32purse]

I vote Quinn for sure

 

[dotty8]

I prefer the pink one (the shape and the colour)

 

[Dooneysta]

If you anticipate using the shoulder strap more than just once in awhile make sure you can accept the unergonomic way they attach to the bag. They both attach the same way, I believe, but I personally find bags shaped like the Quinn to be unusually awkward against the body once the strap is on, whereas the Selena’s shape mitigates it somewhat and also puts less strain on the handles (possibly because the handles are farther apart on Selena’s distributing the weight better).

 

[ZaiGk]

Thanks a tonne guys for your candid and insightful opinion, however, unfortunately the Selena is sold out, my SA just informed me, she says she will call up other Coach stores and ask if they still have one available She says the Quinn is selling fast too, the black is sold out, and just the oxblood is available, other colours too, in the Quinn are sold out! (40% is a good discount). I’m disappointed coz I decided on Selena, but....
It leaves me wid the Quinn now, so Yay or Nay? Thanks much wonderful Coachies

 

[ZigZagHandBagGirl]

Thanks a tonne guys for your candid and insightful opinion, however, unfortunately the Selena is sold out, my SA just informed me, she says she will call up other Coach stores and ask if they still have one available She says the Quinn is selling fast too, the black is sold out, and just the oxblood is available, other colours too, in the Quinn are sold out! (40% is a good discount). I’m disappointed coz I decided on Selena, but....
It leaves me wid the Quinn now, so Yay or Nay? Thanks much wonderful Coachies

I love the Selena! The store by me still has the pink and bordeaux Bond bags.