i would LOVE to take the third...but it is not an option for us now....i feel sad....
Don't feel sad! You are giving two very deserving kitties wonderful new lives! A lot of people let guilt talk them into animals that they either shouldn't have or will wind up overwhelming them. If your limit is 2 cats and you are rescuing 2 babies in need then you are doing everything you can and making sure that those 2 cats have the life of leisure all cats deserve
Congrats on your new family members and I'm looking forward to your pics!
i would take slight heart murmur kitty (because his problem doesn't actually sound a big deal) and 1-eye kitty (because he is completely fine with 1 eye).
The 'healthy' one is sure to find another loving home.
ita!