Please help me decide which bag to keep?

[Restore724]

I think these 2 bag are about the same size. Please help me decide on which bag to keep and why.... (attached sample pics).
Thanks in advance


COACH Leather Carly 10615 (full ziptop)
-- or --
COACH Leather Gallery East/West 12343 (breakaway ziptop)

 

[chinahopes]

i'd keep the carly.. more classic look to me... i'm not a fan of colored leather though, so that could be why.. jmho.

 

[patchworkcat]

Carly

 

[Katwoman1973]

The Carly is a keeper!

 

[remedios03]

Carly

 

[PhantaBitten]

Carly...its a classic and the leather is yummy.

 

[edanna]

Never liked those Gallery Totes since I'm not a fan of structured bags. I prefer a little slouchiness. Therefore, I choose the Carly.

 

[jeh3v]

Carly!

 

[candlee]

For me the two bags have different functions, the Carly a purse for me to use and the Gallery Tote as a kids bag. I have a 3 year old & a 20 month old. That's how I would pick!

 

[lmartinx1]

The Carly's a keeper.

 

[d&blover84]

I 7th that.....CARLY!

 

[psxgurl]

I have two carlys! So I say Carly

 

[Miss Evy Rocks!]

Keep Carly ​

 

[OK Bag Lady]

Another vote for Carly.

 

[KaliDaisy]

I vote for Carly as well