Please help me decide - studds or ring

[Gator bag lady]

Hello all,

I've been losing sleep because I can't decide. Here are the choices:

2.5 carat per ear round studs (5 carat total weight) + simple diamond band

-or-

5.5 carat asscher solitaire diamond ring + .5 carat per ear asscher studs (1 carat total weight)

I honestly feel like I would love both equally and get the same amount of use. Wish I could have both but its not an option. Please help me decide.

 

[dolllover]

Hello all,

I've been losing sleep because I can't decide. Here are the choices:

2.5 carat per ear round studs (5 carat total weight) + simple diamond band

-or-

5.5 carat asscher solitaire diamond ring + .5 carat per ear asscher studs (1 carat total weight)

I honestly feel like I would love both equally and get the same amount of use. Wish I could have both but its not an option. Please help me decide.

I like the second choice.

 

[canyongirl]

I'd go for the 2nd choice as well. The ring you would be able to admire on your hand everyday and still have a nice bit of sparkle for your ears.

 

[NikkisABagGirl]

I think option 2 offers the most versatility.

 

[RedPoppies]

I, too, like the idea of the second option. I wear 1ctw stud earrings and I like the size for everyday wear.

 

[LovingDiamonds]

I'm also for choice number 2!

 

[Swanky]

2, except I'd get round studs

 

[Carnel]

#2 because you will enjoy the ring more since you'll be able to see it all day long.

 

[lilmountaingirl]

Option 2! Omg totally wish i were having this dilemna right now!

 

[karo]

Asscher of course. My dream ring and you'll be seing it a lot more than the earrings.

 

[airiu]

Option 2.

 

[Junkenpo]

I'll be voice on the other end.

I like the first option because I'm not really a ring person. A simple diamond band is elegant and easier to stack.

I think a really nice pair of studs will take you through your whole life with minimal fuss and will go with everything.

 

[skyqueen]

2, except I'd get round studs

I'll be voice on the other end.

I like the first option because I'm not really a ring person. A simple diamond band is elegant and easier to stack.

I think a really nice pair of studs will take you through your whole life with minimal fuss and will go with everything.

Tough choice!
I'm not a ring person either (although I might make an exception in this case) but would get round stones if you go with studs. I have 5 TCW studs martini and they really make a statement.

 

[secw1977]

Option 2 x

 

[benchwarmer]

Chose the 2nd. I bet that Ascher will look amazing and .5 per earring is very tasteful. Lucky you!