Please Help Me Choose :)

[tyrrhenia]

Hello ladies, this is my first time posting in the Coach forum! :shame:

I'm thinking of getting a nice white bag for spring, and I'm considering these two:

Legacy Ali Leather Shoulder Flap

Pebbled Leather Shoulder Tote

Which do you think would be better?
Also, do you think a white bag would get dirty easily?


Thanks in advance!

 

[Coachlover123]

I vote for the Ali, but the shoulder tote is a very classic piece as well. Welcome to the Coach forum!

 

[graberg]

I have the pebbled leather shoulder in camel and I like it but it's a big bag and sometimes feels like a bottomless pit. The clasp that holds it together at the top can also be slightly awkward to manuever around. It sits on the shoulder really well though.

 

[bgcutiepie00]

They are both really nice in white, but I think I like the looks of the tote better myself.

 

[AlohaGirl01]

Ali!

 

[Wildflower]

I love the Ali!!

 

[galen*sgirl]

I vote for the Ali. I had always bypassed her in the store because I thought she was too big but today I tried it on and fell in LOVE. I got the black one though but the white is gorgeous.

 

[SpoiledRotten22]

Ali

 

[tyrrhenia]

Thanks for the input ladies!

I'm leaning towards the Ali now... but I think I'll have to go see them in person and decide!

 

[depthxofxdreams]

personally i like the ali!!

 

[snazzylady]

I have the pebbled white leather tote (haven't used it yet, it isn't after Easter --- LOL) I decided on the tote because it is more classic and I don't see me carrying a white bag everyday, and thought the tote would not be as dated.
Just my 2 cents worth

 

[tyrrhenia]

Thanks depthxofxdreams and snazzylady

I agree that the tote is more classic and will probably be more versatile, too.

tough decisions! ush:

 

[cupcake]

Hi tyrrhenia! Welcome to tPF Coach board! I like both bags but I think I'd pick the Ali if I had to choose between the two. I have nine Legacy pieces (including accessories) and I can't say enough good things about the collection. You really can't go wrong! I am a slave to the Legacy collection!

 

[LizCordova]

Get the Ali. I own two of them, one in whiskey and one in White. I love them both so much.
You will not regret buying this bag. It is one of the best bags Coach has ever made.

 

[rin95]

Ali is my current fav. I also own the shoulder bag ( denim patch ). I say get both!