Please help me choose: YSL Roady or Givenchy Nightingale?

[Chloe_concord]

Today I got two packages. One is YSL black stingray printed hobo , the other is Givenchy Med nightingale dk brown with corset strap. DH said my quote is only for one, so which one? I love them equally though. Anyone has either one of them please chip in?

 

[purse-nality]

pics?!

 

[Janita31]

I have same dilema!! Just bought two bags - one chanel and one givenchy nightingale on sale...don't know what to keep. very hard call...interested to see how others respond..

 

[linhhhuynh]

yes, pictures please!

 

[Chloe_concord]

Sorry about the pics quality since I used phone camera to take quick pics...

 

[purse-nality]

^nightingale for me! Gorgeous gorgeous leather! I seriously wanna burry my face in it! this is so not helping my xmas ban!

 

[Awwgeez]

I agree with purse! Givenchy all the way.

 

[maria-mixalis]

Generally i love both bags..They have good quality of leather and they are durable and classic..But i prefer givenchy!!The corset strap makes it more special.
Keep the Givenchy!!

 

[linhhhuynh]

Givenchy!

 

[Blo0ondi]

well i'm a proud owner of many Givenchy bags n i like roady
go with nightingale... i luv mine soo much
maybe the roady 4 later!

 

[ipudgybear]

Givenchy!!

 

[Beach Bum]

wow..i like both too

BUT......

Givenchy wins....and makes me wanna go buy one..LOL!

 

[raj]

I like the roady

 

[gipursegal]

Roadie!!!!

 

[Straight-Laced]

OP that's a tough decision!!!!

I really like both and the black stingray print lifts the simple style of the roady hobo . . . but I like the Givenchy just a little bit more!!

First because I love this colour and the corset style and second because I have a Nightingale and use it more than any other bag I've ever owned - it just seems to get better with use