Please help me choose: YSL Roady or Givenchy Nightingale?

Feb 27, 2006
955
0
:biggrin:Today I got two packages. One is YSL black stingray printed hobo , the other is Givenchy Med nightingale dk brown with corset strap. DH said my quote is only for one, so which one? I love them equally though. Anyone has either one of them please chip in?
 

Janita31

New Member
Sep 13, 2008
4
0
I have same dilema!! Just bought two bags - one chanel and one givenchy nightingale on sale...don't know what to keep. very hard call...interested to see how others respond..
 

purse-nality

SemiKindCharmedLife
O.G.
Nov 7, 2007
5,791
25
^nightingale for me! Gorgeous gorgeous leather! I seriously wanna burry my face in it! :drool: this is so not helping my xmas ban!
 
Last edited:

maria-mixalis

****fashion****
Sep 30, 2008
455
0
Greece
Generally i love both bags..They have good quality of leather and they are durable and classic..But i prefer givenchy!!The corset strap makes it more special.
Keep the Givenchy!!
 

Blo0ondi

Member
May 26, 2010
2,355
5
Qatar
well i'm a proud owner of many Givenchy bags n i like roady
go with nightingale... i luv mine soo much
maybe the roady 4 later!
 
Oct 21, 2008
4,544
4,070
OP that's a tough decision!!!!

I really like both and the black stingray print lifts the simple style of the roady hobo . . . but I like the Givenchy just a little bit more!!

First because I love this colour and the corset style and second because I have a Nightingale and use it more than any other bag I've ever owned - it just seems to get better with use :smile: