Please help me choose boots!

Feb 13, 2006
I am looking for a new pair of everyday flat boots in black or gray. I narrowed it down to these 3 but I can't choose...please help! Which do you like and in what color? Thank you!

1 -
(only downside to these are that they are suede and I prefer leather just bc it doesn't get messed up as fast)

2 -

3 -
(these also come in black)