Please help me choose between these Tiffany earrings

[carebearz]

I've 2 pairs on hold right now and gotta decide soon.

0.64ct
I colour
VS1
Approx US$4125

or

0.72ct
J colour
VVS1/VVS2
Approx USD$4333

When I place the 2 earrings beside each other, the colour difference was pretty obvious.
The SA advised that the yellow in the J colour wouldn't be that obvious when I have them on my ears and there's nothing to compare them next to.
Furthermore, I've got long hair which makes the J colour less obvious.
So the SA recommended me to take the 2nd pair as the size will make it more 'eye-catching' since my hair is long.

But still I have my reservations on the J colour as I've never gone beyond the colourless spectrum. But at the same time, I do prefer its size.

Which pair would you go for?
Thanks!

 

[ahertz]

I'd go for j. I agree with your SA, color is not that noticeable on ears. But can you drop down on clarity? That's also not noticeable on ears.

 

[neverenoughbags]

For ears j is fine. Go down on clarity too. As long you've got a great cut, that's what will be more noticeable.