Please dont hate me but i have to ask....

[liss06]

Okay so i need your help...
Ive been looking for a pink bag for a while and was bummed when i missed out on the pink patent ergo satchel, but i heard its coming back..
Now i was going to go ahead and purchase it but then i saw another bag that i liked. So now im not sure which to choose. The other is a marc by marc jacobs.
Which do you prefer??
Thank you

Here is the link
http://www.net-a-porter.com/product/33921

and

and of course

 

[CoachJunkie1908]

That Marc Jacbos bag is MUCH bigger than the Ergo, and it's more textured. Do you need a bag that big, or would you prefer something smaller and more structured?

 

[liss06]

I really dont mind it being big. Lol I know they are total opposites.

 

[princesslisa]

I dont like the marc jacobs at all

 

[dazhidayong]

You realize that asking this question on a Coach forum will bring you very biased answers...

However, just going by looks, the ergo is way more my style. The Marc looks a bit shapeless and huge. But if it's size you need, then obviously the Marc.

 

[BagsAreMyBabies]

I'm not sure how biased my answer is because I do own a couple M by MJs, but I also have the ergo and I LOVE that bag which is the one I would go with. Also, I noticed that the MJ says its neon and that shade of pink does not sound appealing.

 

[coachmommyofmin]

I like the ergo better, its big enough not to be hughe (compared to the other one).

 

[Nancy in VA]

Dont be offended but that Marc Jacobs looks like a big pink plastic garbage bag -
I love the pink ergo

 

[:-)]

I love the ergo also

 

[rendodan110]

nah not feeling the marc by marc jacobs at all tooo shopping baggish. I definantly say ergo.

 

[Rapunzel]

I love MJ and I love Coach. They are both at the top of my favourite designers lists in terms of handbags. But, honestly, I have to say I think the MJ bag is hideous. It's gigantic for starters, the detailing makes it look like it has literally been stapled together, and the colour is so 80's neon. Granted, I have a very classic and ladylike taste when it comes to handbags, but even a lover of funky modern styles would have to admit that this MJ is extremely dated. On the other hand, the patent ergo is classic, a good size, not too over the top in detailing, and has a much more tasteful colour.

Please forgive me if I seem too blunt or rude. I would simply hate to see anyone buy a bag that they might look back to regret. IF you truly love the MJ then regardless of what I say you should get it. Just make sure you really love the bag you end up with and can see yourself wearing in a few years, not just right now.

 

[Barlow]

The Coach bag looks much classier IMHO... you could dress it up more easily

 

[kabaker]

I still like the satchel...the marc jacobs bag is just too big for me.

 

[kattykay]

nancy i completely agree with you. as soon as i saw that i thought it looked like a shopping bag from shoprite that had been stretched out

 

[kittykittycatcat]

MJ for sure!!!